It may seem somewhat perverse to complain about birds chirping
outside my window, but when the window is closed and double glazed, then it was
certainly a surprise – an expensive surprise as I had just had spent over
$11,000 on five windows to keep out train noise. Needless to say, if I can hear the birds in
the tree just outside my bedroom window, the Ecostar double glazed windows have done little to
abate noise from trains.
Ecostar provides a convincing demonstration of the
effectiveness of its double glazing.
It sets up a speaker playing loud
music in a sound-proof box, with
double glazed glass on a hinged door. With the
door open, one hears how noisy the music is.
With it closed – the sounds of silence.
I was impressed.
Perhaps even more impressive was the salesman who visited
my house to inspect the bedrooms where the double glazed windows were to be
installed and provide a quote. He assured
me that other people who lived along railway lines had installed Ecostar
windows and were happy with their performance. To back up his point, the salesman showed me a graph
that claimed that the windows can cut noise “by up to 80%.” The words “up to”, of course, is Ecostar’s
escape clause.
After the windows were installed, I gave them the gentlest
of tests — would they cut out the chit-chat between the sparrows perched on the tree just outside my window? They didn’t.
And, as far as cutting out train noise, the windows were a dud.
Is this just a case of “buyer-beware”? Well, no.
When I phoned Ecostar afterwards, they explained that the windows were not
particularly effective in brick veneer houses or ones with a metal roof, not
facts that I knew or could reasonably have known. The company, however, did know this, and as
the salesman had inspected my house, he was in a position to advise me that I could
not expect significant noise abatement for my house. He didn’t.
To be fair, the company promptly sent someone out to inspect the
windows after I complained, and there were a number of emails and phone
calls that followed. But the message coming out of
Ecostar, loud and clear, was that the failure of the windows to perform was the fault of the
construction of my house, not its windows.
Finally, rather than treating my calls as a complaint that needed resolution,
the company treated them as “feedback.”
It was only after I told Ecostar that it wasn’t providing them with “feedback” but that I wanted Ecostar to accept responsibility for not warning me about the limitations of their windows that I finally experienced the sounds of silence. I haven’t
heard from Ecostar since.






